There was a time — and it really wasn't that long ago — when giving a gift that didn't come in crinkly new plastic was simply not done. Giving second-hand was the equivalent of being cheap, or it gave the impression that you'd forgotten and quickly grabbed something from the back of your own cupboard.
Luckily, that stigma is fading fast. In a world full of mass production, a second-hand gift — or to put it more chicly, vintage, or pre-loved — is actually a sign of good taste. It's sustainable, it shows effort, and let's be honest: anyone can buy a pre-packaged gift set at the drugstore. But finding that one rare first edition of a favorite book? Now that is love.
Even so, it still feels a bit unfamiliar to many people. Is it really okay for a birthday? How do you find the real gems among the clutter? And how do you make sure it doesn't look cheap? Time for a mini-guide on how to give a second-hand gift.
More than just your wallet
View on bol →
Of course it's nice for your bank account, but if money is your only reason, you're missing the point. The real power lies in uniqueness. In a thrift shop, you'll find things that nobody else has: not some generic vase found in every interior, but a mouth-blown decanter from the sixties with a story to tell.
Plus, you simply get more bang for your buck. For twenty euros you can buy a new paperback; second-hand, that same amount might buy you a heavyweight coffee table book on architecture that originally cost eighty euros. So you're actually giving a much bigger gift.
Hunting online or in the wild?
View on bol →
The modern treasure hunter doesn't even have to leave the house anymore. Platforms like Vinted have blown the market wide open, and make no mistake: that's long gone past just clothes. Try searching for board games (often still in their plastic wrap because someone got a double), home accessories, or tableware. A golden tip for the hesitant: filter by “new with tags.” That way, it's technically second-hand, but it feels brand new.
For bigger items — a toy kitchen, a designer chair — local classified sites remain unbeatable. Want guaranteed quality and peace of mind? Check out curated platforms like Whoppah for design, or a refurbished shop for electronics with a warranty. Giving a tablet that has been professionally checked over but costs half the price is a smart move nobody will complain about.
And don't underestimate the magic of the physical thrift store. It takes a bit more time and a sharp eye, but the satisfaction is much greater. Head straight for the glassware: old crystal decanters, heavy whiskey glasses, or colored vintage wine glasses are a massive interior trend right now. In a regular boutique you'll pay top dollar, but here they're waiting for a second life for just a euro or two.
The safe bets
View on bol →
Not everything lends itself to a second life as a gift — we'll skip used slippers — but some things are guaranteed hits.
LEGO, for example, is indestructible. A brick from 1980 still fits perfectly onto one from today. A large box of loose bricks or a complete set is a dream for kids (and adult fans alike), and you'll often pay half price. Books and games are also ideal, as long as you double-check that everything is complete and in good condition. A board game like Ticket to Ride easily costs fifty euros new; second-hand you'll often find it for a tenner, barely played.
The difference between “old” and “vintage”
Want your gift to be welcomed with open arms? Then there is one rule that stands head and shoulders above the rest: presentation. Because the item doesn't come in a shiny new box, you are responsible for the wow factor.
First: clean really means clean. Nothing screams “thrift store” quite like an orange price sticker or a layer of dust. Take your time. Remove stickers with a bit of lighter fluid or a hairdryer, wash glassware until it sparkles, let LEGO soak in soapy water for a bit. It needs to feel fresh.
Second: compensate for the lack of factory packaging with your own wrapping skills. Beautiful, thick paper, a real fabric ribbon, or place it in a wooden box with tissue paper.
And finally: be honest and proud of it. Don't pretend it's brand new, because people will see right through that. Tell the story: I stumbled upon this vase and immediately thought of you, it matches your curtains perfectly. Or: I've been searching for this first edition for you for a long time. With that story, you transform a used item into a personal find. And that, ultimately, is the best gift there is.
Frequently asked questions
Is it okay to give a second-hand gift for Christmas?
Definitely. A well-chosen vintage or pre-loved gift shows effort and taste, and it's more sustainable. Just be honest about it and share the story behind it.
Where can you find good second-hand gifts?
At thrift stores, flea markets, antiquarian bookshops, and on second-hand platforms like Vinted. Refurbished electronics are a safe option that come with a warranty.
What should you avoid buying second-hand?
Skincare products, underwear, mattresses, and bicycle helmets are better bought brand new, along with toys whose safety you cannot verify.